2010 NFL Playoff Divisional Round Predictions

Hey all! I thought that the rankings were getting a bit crowded, so I decided to split out this weekend’s predictions into it’s own post. I didn’t go over it last week, so here’s the methodology if it wasn’t clear:

1.) If one team has a beatpath to its opponent, pick them
2.) Otherwise, pick the team with the higher ranking

All clear? Let’s get to it then!

New York Jets versus New England Patriots: This one is clear. The Patriots, besides being the number one team in the league, have a beatpath to the Jets through Chicago. It’s a clear pick for the Patriots.
Baltimore Ravens versus Pittsburgh Steelers: This one is less clear. Neither of these teams have any beatlosses. In my mind, that makes any pick risky, because it means that they’re essentially equal, and their relative positioning is based on tiebreakers. Essentially, you’re only judging them by strength of schedule. Still, we have those tiebreakers for a reason–this reason, in fact. The Ravens are ranked #3, while the Steelers are ranked #6. That’s pretty close, and you could argue that the home field advantage should neutralize it. But that’s not how I roll. It’s a close call, but the pick is the Ravens.
Green Bay Packers versus Atlanta Falcons: Another one without any beatpath relationship. The Falcons have no beatlosses, and the Packers are only under the Patriots. The rankings are clearer, however. The Falcons have a fair amount of support, enough to have them ranked at #7, while the Packers have only 4 teams below them and are ranked #14. The pick is the Falcons.
Seattle Seahawks versus Chicago Bears: Back to a beatpath pick! The Bears have a direct beatpath to the Seahawks. It looks pretty long in the graph, but there are hidden paths (specifically, either NYJ=>HOU or IND=>KC) that shorten it a bit. In any case, the call is clear: the Bears.

So, that’s two beatpath picks (New England over New York and Chicago over Seattle) and two weaker rankings picks (Atlanta over Green Bay and Baltimore over Pittsburgh). The Ravens pick is probably the weakest. Personally, I can’t wait to see how it all shakes out! Enjoy the weekend!

3 Responses to 2010 NFL Playoff Divisional Round Predictions

  1. The MOOSE says:

    My ratings come up with the same results for the Standard method, which isn’t unusual.

    Iterative thinks ATL and GB are both better teams, but still has ATL winning. However, Iterative chooses PIT over BAL.

    Weighted also picks PIT over BAL while also choosing GB over ATL.

  2. JT says:

    Funny how the SEA -> CHI path that stuck around for much of the season was such a big deal, and now that we have a rematch, now the Bears have beatpaths to the Seahawks.

    Just looking at the Bear’s schedule, they had a funky few weeks at home weeks 6 and 7. Against the Seahawks they went 0-12 on 3rd down, which makes it tough to win. Against the Redskins they gave up 6 turnovers (and were -3 in turnovers for the game), also making it hard to win. Looks like they may have straightened things out with the bye week after that.

  3. Kenneth says:

    That’s more or less been the storyline around Chicago; supposedly, during the bye week Lovie (or someone) kicked Martz’s butt until he started running the ball and featuring less 7 step drops. That, and the bye week was when Tice (OL coach) was able to stabilize the line. They had been shifting guys in positions before that, but I believe they’ve started the same set of 5 ever since.

    Personally, I think both of these games were mostly aberrations. The Seahawks game was the first time Cutler had played since the 9 sack debacle against the Giants. He didn’t look comfortable, and the line was still trying to figure things out. The Redskins game, I think is just the kind of game that a guy like Cutler is going to have once a season or so. He kept making awful decisions. But he’s been pretty good ever since. You live with it and move on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *